Our Story
BUILT ON COMMUNITY AND QUALITY
From the food we serve to the welcoming atmosphere we create, we’re always aiming for a home run. Family-owned and operated, our restaurant is more than just a place to eat—it’s a place to celebrate victories and connect with the team that matters most.
Whether you’re swinging by after a game or grabbing a meal with friends, we’re here to serve up great food and championship-worthy memories.
Meet the
HOME TEAM
Family-owned and operated, City Park Pizza has that warm, family-friendly atmosphere that puts everybody at ease. We like to call it home field advantage.
When our owners Trey and Natasha McPhaul met at Gainesville’s Turnstile Deli, Natasha was serving high-quality food, connecting with her customers, and loving every minute of it. Trey was new to the area but eagerly jumped right into the Gainesville community by getting involved with youth sports and community volunteer opportunities.
The McPhaul family loves connecting with neighbors, serving delicious food, and creating lasting memories with their beloved community. Those values are the playbook at City Park Pizza, and we hope you’ll choose to visit our space.
Our Values
THE INGREDIENTS OF WHO WE ARE
COMMUNITY
Whether you’re grabbing your go-to sub after a game or testing out a slice of the Linebacker, we’re here to celebrate your wins, losses, and everything in between. Come on in and make yourself at home!
QUALITY
We use simple, fresh ingredients to make high quality food because the process matters. From hand-tied garlic knots to house-made dressing, only the good stuff made the cut (cue golf clap).
